Brandi Carlile came up with a crazy idea to do a tour where the audience chooses the songs. There was a point in the Human Tour concerts where she’d take requests, and Burn The Setlist evolved from that. A different setlist every night of the tour. Concertgoers make signs with song titles they’d like to hear — eligible songs could be any from her recorded catalog, along with live covers — and the lights are turned up several times during the concert so Brandi could see & make choices, often choosing 2-3 songs at a time. It’s kind of crazy! And so cool. I enjoyed Variety’s review.

One stop on the tour — a two-night stop — was at the Pabst Theater in Milwaukee. It’s a beautiful theater, and I can’t believe I’ve never attended an event there before. Annie snagged tickets for the second night as soon as she was able, and I got to be her lucky date. I drove down to Milwaukee on Sunday afternoon & met her at our accommodations, the upper of a 2-flat owned by Sharon’s old boyfriend and our longtime family friend, Bill. He lives downstairs, and came up to visit while we finished watching (the pathetic) Packers game & made our posters. Normally, the Pabst doesn’t allow signs of any kind, but Ann called to make sure it was OK. (We had a backup plan, just in case!)


Annie made the poster boards & I brought the markers.

It’s been a while since I made anything quite like this.


It was so much fun!

The final products (A-side). Turns out, she didn’t play any of our songs!!

She might have had a hard time seeing us!! haha.

I’m not mad about it. The show was great, lasting about 3 hours, and included Sista Strings (originally from MKE) in addition to the Hanseroth Twins. AND two little girls from the audience were invited up on stage to sing “Crowded Table” with Brandi. It was a moment.
The most hilarious request was one shouted repeatedly… “Roll Out The Barrel”! Someone’s clearly still on a Brewers honeymoon. haha. I don’t know if Brandi’s a baseball fan, or aware of the significance of that song… if not, I’m sure the Sistas filled her in.

Another interesting aspect of this concert — all of the concerts on this tour — is that phones were not allowed. We were given special locked pouches in which to place our phones that were unlocked as we exited. Annie was able to keep hers, on the honor system, because that’s how she adjusts her hearing aids. She let the people around us know, but didn’t need to adjust much. Anyway, it was really nice not to see phones/cameras/lights waving around, and I actually spoke words to people.
And now I’m really hunkering down (mostly) at home until February!
Discover more from knitorious
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

I’ve read several reviews of how wonderful this tour is, and it’s really excellent that you and Anne were there! I’m impressed that there were so many signs, and I’m sure it was even better hearing the songs on those signs. Big fun on a Sunday night!
Sounds like a very fun night!
What an awesome concept for a concert! I’m so glad you and Annie had a chance to go. (I’m envious! I’d love to see Brandi Carlile!) When we saw John Mullaney a couple of years ago, we had to use those locked phone pouches, too. It was a little unnerving — but SO NICE to see no phones out during the performance.